Advice sought

Started by Nirnman, 18 July 2013, 03:00:27 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

Nirnman

sound advice and I've rediscovered my hand at painting, 15's so far I think i'll try a sample pack of 10's and see how a big unit looks at this scale. probably marlburians as I have always found gluing pikes, flags etc to 15s or above messy. I always replaced the flag staffs and spears on fifteens with wire as found them to easily bent and broken

ryman1

Hi Nirnman!  :)

First off I'll echo what fsn said - the Pendraken sculpts allow for blocking in a way other 10mm ranges don't, if you're a beginner you can still be effective at this scale.
I've painted uncountable 6mm figs and that's given me a good grounding, moving into 10mm I now have more room to paint, so if I could give 2 recommendations; firstly undercoat in a 'near black' (vallejo black grey is good).
Secondly, don't be afraid of using bright colours ie - if you want to paint a scarlet coat, go a shade lighter than you normally would then highlight with something a shade lighter than that.
Sounds risky but it's the method I've adopted and so far it's not been knocked down.

The brutal truth is......... if you're new to small scale then prepare for a good few mishaps, the gorgeous truth is.........it won't cost you much with Pendraken figs.
As a final word......crack on, make mistakes, get better than you expect to before you expect to and don't be afraid to try something that seems complicated -  at this scale (if you have the patience), you'll quickly overcome it.

Cheers

Ry

Grenadier

18 July 2013, 11:15:22 PM #17 Last Edit: 18 July 2013, 11:18:51 PM by Grenadier
Welcome Nirnman!  I, like you, had 20+ years pass by when I rediscovered miniature gaming.  I was a staunch 15mm guy but have moved to 6 and 10mm because I like 36-48 figs per battalion.  I am also a huge WSS/GNW fan. I started painting tens at the age of 47 and was surprised at how nicely Pendrakens paint up.  Dive in, try a few packs and have fun. I will say that going the way of the Glorious Revolution is that you may be limiting yourself.  Expand into the Nine Years Wars and WSS and a whole world opens up.
 I am ashamed to say I have lately been tempted with the Warfare Miniature 28mm's stuff....

Brian

Hertsblue

Hi Nirnman. I have to agree with Grenadier that the WSS provides far more scope than the LoA. The figures are perhaps not as good as Clib's wonderful LoA figures, but they are by no means negligible and they look well en masse.



When you realise we're all mad, life makes a lot more sense.

www.rulesdepot.net

Nirnman

yeah it was warfare miniatures figures that put me into the mood to do the glorious revolution and then I saw the availability of stuff in 15 and 10 mm. I was initially drawn to 15 but am definitely edging towards 10 and the pendraken figs are sooo tempting. now I only need to find a decent (make that simple) rule set that will allow for big battalions. That''s where 25/28/30 loos it for me 18 to 20 figure battalions while looking great if well painted just look company sized and in my mind should be reserved for skirmish gaming. I still have sitting on my shelves 36 ECW new model and 48 men Napoleonic Austrian battalions in what was then large 25mm painted and never fought as that was when I left the they at least look rightish especially when facing 12 or so sized fig other units.
AS to rules so far I've looked at Maurice, Corporal John and a few other sets to see if I can find a simple (easy to understand) set  for this period. I guess I was spoiled in that back when active most rules we used where home made (not that they weren't effective and FUN to play) 'Bayonet'  (Napoleonic) was about the only commercial set used in my group.

Nirnman

Hertsblue I love your figures and see you have them base in five six men blocks for the infantry and in six man squadrons for the cavalry. that is the effect that i'm looking for if I can find a suitable rule set that allows for this. May I ask what set you use and how easy is it to operate and if suitable for solo play if I can't find opponents in my area?

BtW I notice that you only use two flags for your French foot back when I first started using Peter Laing figs our group had Three flags for the French Two drapeau d'ordannce and one colonel's colour while the British had only two the kings and regimental colour it certainly looked effective on the table.
I must look out the old marlburian figs and post a few pics so that todays gamers can see what it looked like in the past. I remember that the worst flag I ever had to paint was for a battalion of Gardes Suisse in this scale as every quarter  of the flag had a different order for the piles wavy unlike normal Swiss regiments where each quarter was identical

GordonY

WSS rules, well you could do worse than Might and Reason by Sam Mustapha, number of figures on the base irrelevant (means cram as many as you like onto the base, 60mm x 30mm, means a whole heap of 10mm) 2 bases to the unit, available as a PDF from the authors website, about £11 (dunno what that is in dollars). Also covers the 7YW, but thats it, its very period specific, the only bad thing I've read about it is that the Prussians are pretty much unbeatable, so simple, choose 2 armies so that neither are Prussian. I've got it, read it but never played it, only because of my ADD, or as I like to think of it my "Oh SHINEY!!!" syndrome, at the moment I'm struggling with building some 1:1200 Nappy ships and some 1:600 Ancient galleys along with 15mm Orcs for HOTT. Who said that one project at a time was sensible?

Fenton

What about Age of Honour by the people who did Age of Eagles?

http://www.ageofeagles.com/Pages/ScenarioBooks.aspx
If I were creating Pendraken I wouldn't mess about with Romans and  Mongols  I would have started with Centurions , eight o'clock, Day One!

Hertsblue

Quote from: Nirnman on 19 July 2013, 08:48:47 AM
Hertsblue I love your figures and see you have them base in five six men blocks for the infantry and in six man squadrons for the cavalry. that is the effect that i'm looking for if I can find a suitable rule set that allows for this. May I ask what set you use and how easy is it to operate and if suitable for solo play if I can't find opponents in my area?

BtW I notice that you only use two flags for your French foot back when I first started using Peter Laing figs our group had Three flags for the French Two drapeau d'ordannce and one colonel's colour while the British had only two the kings and regimental colour it certainly looked effective on the table.
I must look out the old marlburian figs and post a few pics so that todays gamers can see what it looked like in the past. I remember that the worst flag I ever had to paint was for a battalion of Gardes Suisse in this scale as every quarter  of the flag had a different order for the piles wavy unlike normal Swiss regiments where each quarter was identical

After years of hunting around various basing systems I opted for the square 20 x 20mm variety as the most flexible - you can make a reasonably convincing column of route or a line of battle from them. Each "element" represents 100 infantry so the number of elements varies with nationality. My Bavarian battalions have six elements whilst my British and Dutch, with their platoon-firing organisation, have eight - albeit with fewer figures per base. Likewise, the squadrons vary from five figures (French) up to seven (Danish Lifeguards).

You may well be right about the number of standards per battalion. At the time (about seven years ago) I had limited info on the subject and as I was hand-painting the flags I drew the line at two each. In point of fact, I now believe that there was only one colonel's colour per regiment, the second and subsequent battalions carrying two drapeaux d'ordonnance.

As for rules, I use my own Corporal John rules. If you go to http://rulesdepot.net/index.html you can view and download them free.   
When you realise we're all mad, life makes a lot more sense.

www.rulesdepot.net

Nirnman

I downloaded Corporal John but was put off to find that it stated that pike element must be fielded for every four elements of musketeers.  I didn't see any pikes in your units so are you treating this as optional? I was going to use a 30x 30 base as I have a lot of spare peter pig bases in this size but 20x 20 seems reasonable. I can understand the reasoning for the different number fo elements by nationality/firing system but  how did you determine the number of bases/elements for which nationality I skimmed through the rules but didn't see any nationality tables?

You're right about the flags but back when I started we just made our regiments one battalion strong and three flags for the frogs, etc looked the part. if one was being truly accurate yjeir is a case for each company to have its own flag and unless scaling at one to one that is unfeasible.

Nirnman

Hertsblue have just re skimmed through my pdf of Corporal John and see where you are coming from on base size and basing. However just noticed I had no appendix which probably details who use platoon fire etc and cannot find the quality factor for troops anywhere either I must have got a duff download.

Friedland

I'd definitely stick with 10mm.

Very cost effective if you're gaming on a tight budget. Like yourself I've got a large collection of both 15mm and 28mm armies. Even though the 28mm stuff looks impressive once painted, the sheer cost and time can sometimes prove frustrating. For example it's taken me around three years to get (albeit) a very large French Napoleonic Army, and with a fair few Perrys plastics thrown in it's still a lot of money invested.

When you consider that a twenty four man (metal) regiment would likely set you back about £25 at the very least - whereas the same price would get you a whole Pendraken 10mm starter army - it's a veritable bargain.

I'm also the same when it comes to space, and being able to play a decent game within certain confines is important. Unfortunately most of my 28mm games had to wait for the space available to me at my local club, but now in 10mm I can run through a game whenever I want in the modestly sized back room.

On the subject of gaming, I wouldn't be surprised if you end up bumping into someone on one of the many gaming forums who doesn't live too far away (you'd be surprised). Also having mentioned that you live in N.I. if you find yourself passing through Belfast you could always swing by "The Modellers Nook" ( 17 Winetavern St  Belfast BT1 1JQ
028 9023 3862). I usually drop by when I travel over to Belfast. The guy who runs it is a lovely bloke and I'm sure he'd be happy to put up a notice asking for other gamers interested in your specific periods. He usually deals in plastic vehicle kits, but has also started stocking figures. Last time I was there I had a long discussion with a fellow customer on painting French Napoleonic uniforms!

Fenton

Belfast?...I'm there!...So is Irregular Wars..well close enough to  Belfast anyway
If I were creating Pendraken I wouldn't mess about with Romans and  Mongols  I would have started with Centurions , eight o'clock, Day One!

Fenton

Here is some of the WSS I painted up about 10 years ago for an aborted project...






If I were creating Pendraken I wouldn't mess about with Romans and  Mongols  I would have started with Centurions , eight o'clock, Day One!

Nirnman

nice figures fenton  what rules were you going to use? and Belfast definitely not!!am from outside it. Newtownards actually. Friedland know Joe in the modellers nook quite well used to game with him years ago. have all but lost contact with those I gamed with back the work and other things got in the way now redundant and with time on my hands hoping to pick up again.