Pendraken Miniatures Forum

Pendraken News & Info! => General Pendraken => Topic started by: Gwydion on 31 October 2026, 08:26:27 PM

Title: StuG III G and StuH 42 105mm Question
Post by: Gwydion on 31 October 2026, 08:26:27 PM
This is weird and old, not a complaint but I am fascinated to know the answer  (if there is one)
Last December my daughter bought me these - GRV38 and GRV36 respectively. I stuck them together, painted them up, played with them, great.
Then today I looked at the pictures in the catalogue.
The catalogue models both have a top hatch up. Mine don't and have no option for up or down.
Am I going crazy or has something changed?
Yours on hallowe'en...
(Serious question - why the difference?)
Title: Re: StuG III G and StuH 42 105mm Question
Post by: kustenjaeger on 31 October 2026, 09:07:51 PM
I suspect that what you are seeing is the MG shield?

Edward
Title: Re: StuG III G and StuH 42 105mm Question
Post by: Gwydion on 31 October 2026, 09:41:20 PM
Very possibly - but it isn't on my model. :D(https://www.pendraken.co.uk/user/products/stug-iii-ausf-g.-3876-p.jpg)
The raised square item on the right of the top box (far side in this photo). My model does not have this - it is flush to the deck.
Title: Re: StuG III G and StuH 42 105mm Question
Post by: Ithoriel on 01 November 2026, 11:17:34 AM
The German WW2 vehicles were revamped a little while ago. Possible you have the previous version?

If so, you now, in true GW fanboi style, need to replace all your old models with the current ones   :d :d :d :d


Edit: I'm slightly horrified to find that the change was not a year or two ago but back in December 2020!
Title: Re: StuG III G and StuH 42 105mm Question
Post by: Gwydion on 01 November 2026, 01:23:48 PM
Okay - must be very old 'stock' then! - bought, as I say - 11 months ago by my daughter (under close supervision - I sent her the order!).
I'm very happy with the version I have, although I remain confused about what it may actually be! Can't see any variants in the catalogue that look anything like mine.
Title: Re: StuG III G and StuH 42 105mm Question
Post by: Leon on 01 November 2026, 08:24:41 PM
It sounds like the older model but they would have to have been bought quite a few years ago as we don't hold any old stock after something has been upgraded.  If you've got a pic of it, I can check with the casters and see what's happened?
Title: Re: StuG III G and StuH 42 105mm Question
Post by: Gwydion on 01 November 2026, 09:32:15 PM
Hi Leon - I am honestly not complaining about this, just...interested.
(http://corrigenda.pbworks.com/f/StuH%2042%20and%20Stug%20III%20G.jpg)
(http://corrigenda.pbworks.com/f/StuH%2042%20underside.JPG)
Title: Re: StuG III G and StuH 42 105mm Question
Post by: Leon on 01 November 2026, 09:37:08 PM
Quote from: Gwydion on 01 November 2026, 09:32:15 PMHi Leon - I am honestly not complaining about this, just...interested.

That's interesting, they look like our models but I'm not sure why that hatch would be flattened down.  Curious!
Title: Re: StuG III G and StuH 42 105mm Question
Post by: Gwydion on 01 November 2026, 09:48:55 PM
I promise I didn't take a Dremel or a hammer to them! I can think of better ways of spending my time - like working out why 2 coats of Testors has left them that shiny (probably too old).
Anyway, nice to know its not just me that's confused!
Title: Re: StuG III G and StuH 42 105mm Question
Post by: flamingpig0 on 02 November 2026, 08:26:41 AM
Quote from: Gwydion on 01 November 2026, 09:32:15 PMHi Leon - I am honestly not complaining about this, just...interested.
(http://corrigenda.pbworks.com/f/StuH%2042%20and%20Stug%20III%20G.jpg)
(http://corrigenda.pbworks.com/f/StuH%2042%20underside.JPG)


They look good anyway
Title: Re: StuG III G and StuH 42 105mm Question
Post by: Steve J on 02 November 2026, 09:07:42 AM
I just checked my old Stug III's and the ones shown do not look like mine. The underside is different, with the 'name' modelled into the bottom rather than scratched on. Also the 'mg hatch' is more detailed on yours, with mine just scratched in. Also there is an axe sculpted in by the air intake vents, which is not shown on yours.

Worth bearing in mind that my models are rather old (20 years or so), but I thinnk there was no change before the new sculpts appeared with the seperate tracks etc.
Title: Re: StuG III G and StuH 42 105mm Question
Post by: Big Insect on 02 November 2026, 10:16:39 AM
It's probably one of those exceedingly  rare 'Cuckoo StuGs' that fly west to lay their eggs in the nests of other unsuspecting AFVs, which raise them as their own  :-\
A collectors item.  ;D
Title: Re: StuG III G and StuH 42 105mm Question
Post by: Big Insect on 02 November 2026, 10:19:51 AM
On a more 'serious' note: the machine gun (MG) shield on a StuG III Ausf. G laid flat when it was out of use.
The shield was propped up and held in the upright position by the loader's hatch (using a latch or pin connection to the forward half of the hatch).
When the loader's hatch was closed or opened fully, the support was released, and the MG shield fell forward to lie flat against the superstructure roof.
Title: Re: StuG III G and StuH 42 105mm Question
Post by: Gwydion on 04 November 2026, 01:01:57 AM
Well, thanks all.
No definite answers then?
Mystery package (very nice but not apparently current or old Stug III) - an aborted experimental objekt perhaps?
If it is a 'collector's item', I am open to offers starting at £20 each!

Title: Re: StuG III G and StuH 42 105mm Question
Post by: Gwydion on 09 November 2026, 12:21:31 AM
Is that really it?
Not the new model. Not the old model.
What is it then?
Definitely from Pendraken.
A caster's/deigner's experimental effort?
If I order another GRV38 and GRV36 will I get the the ones with the mg mantlet? Or the ones I have? If I wanted more like the ones I've got, what would I order? Or was it a portal to another dimension?
Nobody else experienced this? Just me? I know I'm special but...
Title: Re: StuG III G and StuH 42 105mm Question
Post by: Leon on 09 November 2026, 02:23:51 AM
Dave's been off for a week or so, so I've not had chance to check with him yet.  If you shoot me an email I can ask him when he's back on Monday.
Title: Re: StuG III G and StuH 42 105mm Question
Post by: Ithoriel on 09 November 2026, 12:51:40 PM
Just dragged my WW2 stuff out from under the bed and yours do look very like the ones I have, which are the previous incarnation of the current Pendraken ones.

They are based so I cant compare the undersides.

I'll try to get a couple of decent pictures and post them here for comparison.
Title: Re: StuG III G and StuH 42 105mm Question
Post by: Gwydion on 09 November 2026, 01:13:02 PM
Thanks Leon, Thanks Ithoriel. I had sort of abandoned the previous iteration of Pendraken's Stug based on what Steve said. Happy to be wrong for my sanity's sake!
 
Title: Re: StuG III G and StuH 42 105mm Question
Post by: Ithoriel on 09 November 2026, 03:13:27 PM
Some images, taken with camera phone and not in the best light but hopefully you can see enough detail.


(https://imagizer.imageshack.com/img923/5345/j9L0wQ.jpg)
(https://imagizer.imageshack.com/img924/2134/oMcibB.jpg)
(https://imagizer.imageshack.com/img923/8684/sGUIls.jpg)
(https://imagizer.imageshack.com/img924/1037/i3KEWX.jpg)
(https://imagizer.imageshack.com/img923/2213/mTUXbh.jpg)
Title: Re: StuG III G and StuH 42 105mm Question
Post by: Steve J on 09 November 2026, 03:25:40 PM
You can just make out the axe by the engine intakes and the lack of detail on the mg hatch. these do look the same as mine. Confused as everyone else!!!
Title: Re: StuG III G and StuH 42 105mm Question
Post by: Gwydion on 09 November 2026, 05:19:37 PM
Okay, pretty sure this is different from the thing I've got!
Yours has the round fighting compartment ventillator on the rear of the casemate - mine don't.
I have four engine compartment covers on the rear deck - the left three obviously raised the right one flat, yours too I think, but to the rear of these between the spare wheels you have raised box like construction (sorry don't know what it is) but mine doesn't have that.
To the left of the left spare wheel you have a tubular object, more or less aligned front to back but with the front slightly canted out. On mine there is a similar tubular object but running broadly sid to side and the left canted slightly back.
The front track guards don't seem quite as defined on yours.
Thanks Ithoriel. Much appreciated.
(There may be a couple of other differences but I am starting to see things that aren't there and missing things that are! - I suppose the camo is working at any rate!)

Steve - Talking of not seeing things - I can't for the life of me see an axe anywhere! Sorry. I can see the hatch differences, but an axe? No (and I really want to see it!)
Thanks chaps.
Title: Re: StuG III G and StuH 42 105mm Question
Post by: Steve J on 09 November 2026, 05:56:57 PM
So if you look at the left hand image,on the right hand side mudguard towards the rear, just behind the main superstructure, you can see the axe. It is not modelled on the right hand image though.

(https://imagizer.imageshack.com/img923/2213/mTUXbh.jpg)
Title: Re: StuG III G and StuH 42 105mm Question
Post by: Gwydion on 09 November 2026, 06:39:47 PM
Thanks Steve!
Weird isn't it? Now I've seen it I can't unsee it.
It's obvious!
I think I thought it was part of a grille or something - no can't explain it! It's an axe innit?!
Definitely NOT on mine though!
Title: Re: StuG III G and StuH 42 105mm Question
Post by: Ithoriel on 09 November 2026, 07:00:17 PM
Yes, indeed the StuGIII on the left of my picture has an axe, right rear.

The other one, being the StuH42 doesn't. Neither, Gwydion, does yours.

Cant see the StuGIII well enough in your image to see if it has one or not. It is fairly low relief on mine, so easy to miss.

None of this is helped any by my StuG having Schürzen fitted.
Title: Re: StuG III G and StuH 42 105mm Question
Post by: Leon on 12 November 2026, 11:22:58 AM
I've just checked this with Dave and the top hatch is a separate piece so needs to be glued into the model.  It's a really small square of metal though, so may have been lost/fallen off somewhere?  The written 'Stug III' under the hull is the same as our model here.
Title: Re: StuG III G and StuH 42 105mm Question
Post by: Gwydion on 12 November 2026, 01:41:05 PM
Leon, thanks so much for putting up with my maunderings on this!
Happy now!
I don't know what happened to the mantlets. I did wonder if they were separate but looking on the info on the pictures, they list '1 hull, 1 barrel, 2 tracks' so I discounted that idea. Definitely never stuck them on and don't remember seeing them at all, but as they were a Christmas present from my daughter I don't think I would remember whether they were in the packets or not.  Don't care though! I'm very happy with how they look and now I know there is a simple answer I am a very happy bunny.
Thanks.

Quick rewrite!
It occurred to me I rarely throw away the little plastic bags figures come in as I find uses for them (sometimes). So I spent the last twenty minutes ferreting in my bits boxes down to the archaeological layer of a year ago - Sorry Leon! Two bags with two tiny mantlets! To you and everyone else involved in this saga - my apologies and if I ever start rambling again just say 'mantlets' and I will get straight back in my box! :-[
Title: Re: StuG III G and StuH 42 105mm Question
Post by: Duke Speedy of Leighton on 12 November 2026, 03:18:14 PM
As long as the mantlet holds, there will be no breach in this relationship.
Title: Re: StuG III G and StuH 42 105mm Question
Post by: Leon on 12 November 2026, 04:11:26 PM
Quote from: Gwydion on 12 November 2026, 01:41:05 PMQuick rewrite!
It occurred to me I rarely throw away the little plastic bags figures come in as I find uses for them (sometimes). So I spent the last twenty minutes ferreting in my bits boxes down to the archaeological layer of a year ago - Sorry Leon! Two bags with two tiny mantlets! To you and everyone else involved in this saga - my apologies and if I ever start rambling again just say 'mantlets' and I will get straight back in my box! :-[

Excellent, good to hear that you've got them!
Title: Re: StuG III G and StuH 42 105mm Question
Post by: Ithoriel on 12 November 2026, 07:42:53 PM
Quote from: Gwydion on 12 November 2026, 01:41:05 PMTo you and everyone else involved in this saga - my apologies and if I ever start rambling again just say 'mantlets' and I will get straight back in my box! :-[

To be fair I looked at the list of parts and thought the mantlets must be cast on.

However ....

Enquiring minds want to know!

And

No stupid questions, only stupid answers!

Glad we got there in the end.
Title: Re: StuG III G and StuH 42 105mm Question
Post by: Raider4 on 12 November 2026, 08:01:49 PM
Quote from: Gwydion on 12 November 2026, 01:41:05 PM... To you and everyone else involved in this saga - my apologies... 
No need, it's been gripping stuff. "The Mystery of the Missing Mantlets"! Two weeks of high quality entertainment. 
Title: Re: StuG III G and StuH 42 105mm Question
Post by: Gwydion on 12 November 2026, 09:53:00 PM
Thing was, I didn't even know they were missing until today!
Last reel plot twist!
Title: Re: StuG III G and StuH 42 105mm Question
Post by: Gwydion on 12 November 2026, 11:02:20 PM
One good thing came of it however, it made me respray them with Windsor and Newton Matt varnish:

(http://corrigenda.pbworks.com/f/Stug%20and%20StuH%20and%20mantlets.JPG)
(with the missing mantlets safely in their bags!)

Okay - appear to now be unable to post pics of non-shiny afvs- I should have quit while I was ahead.
Finally!