Pendraken Miniatures Forum

Pendraken Rules! => Blitzkrieg Commander IV => BKC-IV Battles => Topic started by: Duke Speedy of Leighton on 20 October 2026, 11:53:09 PM

Title: 1938 Poland s German
Post by: Duke Speedy of Leighton on 20 October 2026, 11:53:09 PM
Quick report on last week's game.
https://madlemmey.blogspot.com/2026/10/blitzkrieg-commander-iv-poles-vs.html
Title: Re: 1938 Poland s German
Post by: Steve J on 21 October 2026, 05:38:32 AM
Great to see the Poles in action Will 8) !
Title: Re: 1938 Poland s German
Post by: Techno 3 on 21 October 2026, 05:53:43 AM
:-bd
Title: Re: 1938 Poland s German
Post by: sultanbev on 21 October 2026, 09:19:23 AM
Er, StuG III in 1939? Oh dear, that's an army list error of epic proportions, especially under a CV10 commander. Yes, they would have been that good, if they existed at the time.

The first mild-steel plated 5x StuG IIIA-0 appeared in service in October 1939, full proper StuG IIIA in March 1940. I would demand a refight.
Title: Re: 1938 Poland s German
Post by: Big Insect on 21 October 2026, 10:08:43 AM
The whole issue of CV10 commanders is one that will probably 'rumble' on and on (& on).
But great to see the Poles in action and actually doing as well as they did.

I'll check the lists regarding the StuG's ....
Cheers
Mark
Title: Re: 1938 Poland s German
Post by: sultanbev on 21 October 2026, 10:37:33 AM
For me I have no problem with CV10 commanders, it is an accurate reflection of the differences between levels of training as far as I'm concerned, especially for Cold War. The CV7-10 system works well in my own tactical rules, and I've finally got it to work in Napoleonic-19th century wargames.
Title: Re: 1938 Poland s German
Post by: fred. on 21 October 2026, 12:00:08 PM
Is there a limit on the number of successful commands a HQ can issue? I know in latest fan revisions of Warmaster it is capped at 3 successes per commander. Makes CV10 good, but not all powerful - and perhaps more so in BKC/CWC where shooting is ordered. 

I've had high command units sit on a hill with a mortar unit and get so many shots off it becomes a bit silly. 
Title: Re: 1938 Poland s German
Post by: sunjester on 21 October 2026, 12:55:19 PM
Quote from: sultanbev on 21 October 2026, 09:19:23 AMEr, StuG III in 1939? Oh dear, that's an army list error of epic proportions, especially under a CV10 commander. Yes, they would have been that good, if they existed at the time.

The first mild-steel plated 5x StuG IIIA-0 appeared in service in October 1939, full proper StuG IIIA in March 1940. I would demand a refight.
Especially true as this engagement was set in 1938! At least according to Will's heading :D )

Sounds like a fun game.
Title: Re: 1938 Poland s German
Post by: sultanbev on 21 October 2026, 01:34:33 PM
Quote from: sunjester on 21 October 2026, 12:55:19 PMEspecially true as this engagement was set in 1938! At least according to Will's heading
Yes, I saw that - it would make it even worse, as there were no Panzer IIIE or TKS+20mm in 1938; the Germans would have been on Panzer IIIC/D with 14mm armour, although in BKC I'm not sure that makes any difference to those with 30mm armour.
Title: Re: 1938 Poland s German
Post by: Duke Speedy of Leighton on 21 October 2026, 09:19:03 PM
It was meant to be 39, typo in the title!

Oops
Let me know on the Stugs! Please nerf them as it will EEALLY annoy Dave!   :d
Title: Re: 1938 Poland s German
Post by: Steve J on 22 October 2026, 05:36:37 AM
Yep, the Stug III's only appeared in the French campaign and in limited numbers.
Title: Re: 1938 Poland s German
Post by: Big Insect on 22 October 2026, 08:57:46 AM
Quote from: fred. on 21 October 2026, 12:00:08 PMIs there a limit on the number of successful commands a HQ can issue? I know in latest fan revisions of Warmaster it is capped at 3 successes per commander. Makes CV10 good, but not all powerful - and perhaps more so in BKC/CWC where shooting is ordered.

I've had high command units sit on a hill with a mortar unit and get so many shots off it becomes a bit silly.

No limit as it is very dice dependent - The differences between Warmaster & Commander mechanisms is that the 'Commander' commanders can also drop previously commanded units (as long as they have not failed a roll or blundered) and move on to attempting to command another formation. The idea is to provide a fluid and flexible game.
Title: Re: 1938 Poland s German
Post by: sultanbev on 22 October 2026, 09:45:31 AM
I once had a CV10 unit do 8 activations (Panzer III CHQ platoon in a Barbarossa game*), still didn't achieve much. I can't remember why but it was hull down shooting at tanks. I do remember the same game had a Russian armoured train in it, that blundered on it's first activation and derailed itself, thereby also not doing much other than providing a target for Stukas.
In another a CV7 unit of Zrinyi assault guns got something like 6 activations, but they spent most of it moving up into firing range and missing completely.
Yes, don't be afraid of multiple activations!

*we use the CV system applied to units as apposed to commanders, for a tactical 1:1 game. So CHQs are combat units as well as vital for command and morale purposes.