Morning all (Orcs, quiet about me posting during the weekday daytime - I'm on leave!)
Question about medieval combat.
As mentioned elsewhere, I tend towards the 'splody stick end of things - Sunjester is the stabby stick one.
I've recently got Fields of Glory 11 - Medieval.
Battles start with two lines (with a 2nd line of gap pluggers). After a bit of skirmishing where the archers muck about, the two lines crash into each other.
As units start to retreat, gaps appear in the line. The now freed winner then can help the unit to their side out. This means the battle devolves into a number of pockets of fights, until one side frees a big enough flank to sweep across the line.
My questions...
1) is this also normal in actual tabletop wargaming?
2) Was it normal in actual historic battles?
Thanks
Sounds about right
What is your rough date range for medieval?
About 1100 to about 1500
Thanks, that seems to be the way it normally plays out on the tabletop (unless some sort of army break point is used).
Historical, when one side begins to waver and 2nd line begins to retreat it often quickly devolved into a rout. (The reason for army break points in some rule).
In FoG when a unit breaks, adjacent units have to make a morale test.
Quote from: Last Hussar on 06 January 2026, 02:36:53 PMSunjester is the stabby stick one.
At what point have I ever stated this? :-\
I tend to find this is what happens in most games - turning a flank is key. With Hail Caesar it often came down to which unit your heavy cavalry could overmatch the best, break them and pivot into the flank of the adjacent unit.
As to what happened in actual battles - most approximately real time accounts rarely go into this level of detail.
Medieval battles were not all as simple as that. Unlike wargamers, who tend to want every unit in the front line, even Medieval generals tried to keep a reserve and they tried ruses and stratagems too. True, we don't know the nitty-gritty of a lot of battles, but we do know enough to know that command and control was just as important then as it was in earlier and later times. Look to Byzantine military manuals and see that they are just as sophisticated as those of the 17th & 18th centuries.
That's a good point, one I try to remind myself of. Modern people think history was stupid; they weren't, they just didn't have our technology, so of course it was more basic.
I have been keeping a second line, but that plugs gaps as front line units rout. I wonder how it really went; we tend to go for solid unbroken lines.
I know the Romans used a checkerboard formation, I wonder how that works.
If I can ever get the designer function to work, I am going to set up various learning scenarios, to try and teach myself what was passed down 800 years ago.
Bonus point. An example of things they knew in the 13th century. Snails in manuscripts. Look at medieval manuscripts, the margins have lots of pictures of giant snails; knights killing snails, snails killing knights, knights riding snails in jousts.
We just don't know why. It is theorised that this was a well known representation of something in the Middle Ages, so well known, nobody thought to write it down. And then the reason was forgotten.
Combat from the period may be the same.
To me the checker-board formation makes no sense as a combat formation but a lot of sense as a formation when advancing the the point where the battle line will be formed. I don't imagine we will ever know if or how it was used.
I do wish the ancients had had the sense to explain things properly. ;D
No forethought, clearly.
Don't forget the rabbits. They were equal to the snails and more expressive.
QuoteTo me the checker-board formation makes no sense as a combat formation but a lot of sense as a formation when advancing the the point where the battle line will be formed. I don't imagine we will ever know if or how it was used.
I do wish the ancients had had the sense to explain things properly. ;D
No forethought, clearly.
There's all manner of speculation among reenactors and the more geometrically minded historian.
I'm not aware of any existing drill manuals that solve the mystery.
As we well know, contemporary art simply adds confusion.
It is unfortunately impractical to assemble enough reenactors to do much drill.
That leaves historians and diagrams, with three main hypotheses.
1. The gaps in the front line are small enough to represent a kill box which no sensible enemy will enter.
This relies on sensible enemy (a catch-22 when the enemy have already taken arms against the military power of the age).
It also assumes a roman formation that doesn't respond to enemy action.
2. The Romans are drilled to fight with at least three frontal densities. Packed in similar to testudo, ordinary for marching and shield work, more open for fencing against lighter enemy.
This idea says the gaps in each line are filled if a formation deploys into the open order.
3. The second line will quickly advance into the gaps to present a solid shieldwall when needed.
This combines with #1 against "impetuous" enemy, who charge and hit the frontline, but are countercharged by the second line in the gaps.
In reality there's probably a little of each happening depending on the skill and training of the Legion.
Big battle wargaming tends to regiment us into thinking about troops in fixed geometry blocks - unable to negotiate that 38mm wide gap.
I find it helpful to imagine what's taking place within an imaginary "zone of control".
QuoteDon't forget the rabbits. They were equal to the snails and more expressive.
(https://i.imgflip.com/58sq29.jpg)
Quote from: d_Guy on 07 January 2026, 03:42:10 AMDon't forget the rabbits. They were equal to the snails and more expressive.
Bastards!
Quote from: fred. on 06 January 2026, 07:03:39 PMI tend to find this is what happens in most games - turning a flank is key. With Hail Caesar it often came down to which unit your heavy cavalry could overmatch the best, break them and pivot into the flank of the adjacent unit.
As to what happened in actual battles - most approximately real time accounts rarely go into this level of detail.
Which historically is actually a nonsense.
Very few ancient battles and fewer 'medieval' ones are decided by a force winning on a flank and turning the flank of its opponent. Most classical ancient battles have the cavalry (on the flanks) seeing off their opposite number and then rushing off the field after them. There are (of course) notable exceptions (much quoted instances of returning victorious Carthaginian cavalry wings being the case regularly cited). But most cavalry forces were spent by the time they defeated their opposite numbers and most battles are won by breakthroughs in the centre.
With regards to 'medieval' battles - even in large battles its mostly about retinues. You read of this lords retinue (or household troops etc.) breaking and leaving a gap and that weakens the line which then collapses into a series of vicious 'scrums' until one side has had enough. The loyalty of retainers to their lieges is why in certain battles you can get such high casualties - Towton is a good example. It is often stated (with no good authority) that it was the asymmetrical archery dual that caused the high casualty rate, but if you review Towton through another lens, it was also one of the WotR battles with the highest number of nobles involved, on both sides.
It's why town levies like Coventry and York etc. were not really viewed as being as good as the retinues, as they has limited loyalty and staying power. Even the 'professional' garrison at Calais was viewed as 'flakey' outside the defense of the town and its pale.
Pretty fowl, Mike.
Dad jokes aside... =)
That makes some sort of sense - an infantry 'base' is usually 8 figures, cavalry 3. The manual/rules states 60:1 figure scale, but at the number reported in-game, it appears more like 40:1. A local retinue of about 320 seems reasonable (to someone who knows very little about gaming the period). When a unit breaks, the adjacent units take a morale test, but this could be more 'beggar'*, there's a gap' rather than 'Young Jonny has run off'.
*Other words available.
Most rules focus far more on combat and its effects rather than the morale side of battle - I think there is a lot of wargames habit / familiarity here. We are used to rolling dice and killing things.
Morale affects are there, but they are often secondary to weapons, armour and their impacts on the game.
But I'm not sure a morale centric game would really appeal to people - or not to those of us who have spent decades playing games that conform to a expected norm of rules behaviour!
And earlier when I referred to flank - I was thinking more of smashing a hole in the line, and turning into the flank of the next unit. Rather than the flank of the whole army.
Quote from: d_Guy on 07 January 2026, 03:42:10 AMDon't forget the rabbits. They were equal to the snails and more expressive.
(https://live.staticflickr.com/65535/55028163252_a31c362321_b.jpg)
Dangerous singly, but a walk* of snails can be lethal if they can corner you.
*Yes, that is one of the collective terms for snails.
QuoteI was thinking more of smashing a hole in the line, and turning into the flank of the next unit. Rather than the flank of the whole army.
This is pretty much what happens in FoG, as mentioned above. Apart from the questionable melee results against archers, it's a pretty good tabletop game. It just happens to be on a computer.
One of the things I like about the Strength and Honour rules is that units don't really take casualties though they may break due to adverse morale checks and the army as a whole may collapse if it suffers enough adverse events.
QuoteAnd earlier when I referred to flank - I was thinking more of smashing a hole in the line, and turning into the flank of the next unit. Rather than the flank of the whole army.
I think that was not uncommon, with the less committed sloping off early. Sometimes one whole flank of the army is winning while the other is losing.
Quote(https://live.staticflickr.com/65535/55028163252_a31c362321_b.jpg)
Dangerous singly, but a walk* of snails can be lethal if they can corner you.
*Yes, that is one of the collective terms for snails.
What!!!
Are these your figures fsn, if so I commend you on the snail trails...
Quote(https://live.staticflickr.com/65535/55028163252_a31c362321_b.jpg)
Dangerous singly, but a walk* of snails can be lethal if they can corner you.
*Yes, that is one of the collective terms for snails.
Desperate measures lads - pass the salt.
Quote from: fred. on 07 January 2026, 05:41:06 PMAnd earlier when I referred to flank - I was thinking more of smashing a hole in the line, and turning into the flank of the next unit. Rather than the flank of the whole army.
Even then fred, I think it was exceptionally rare. Most soldiers/warriors are more concerned about protecting their own rears and flanks than exploiting an opportunity of wheeling and attacking an exposed enemy flank. I can see the formation advancing forward into a gap it has created and lending assistance to its own friendly flank units, but the blokes on the end of a line would be mighty cautious about exposing their own back or flanks.
Cheers
Mark
Quote from: Last Hussar on 07 January 2026, 06:21:16 PMThis is pretty much what happens in FoG, as mentioned above. Apart from the questionable melee results against archers, it's a pretty good tabletop game. It just happens to be on a computer.
I've got just about every FOG book available (I think) - so let me know if you want any of them? - although they are the original version - so I am not too sure how relevant they are any more.
I've moved on to ADLG.
Most sets of rules also handle exhaustion and attrition very poorly as it adds an extra layer of bookkeeping to an already overloaded gamers mind.
Armati handled both the issue of making breakthrough flanking movements and combat fatigue very well - but it produced a game, that whilst realistic was not popular.
QuoteEven then fred, I think it was exceptionally rare. Most soldiers/warriors are more concerned about protecting their own rears and flanks than exploiting an opportunity of wheeling and attacking an exposed enemy flank. I can see the formation advancing forward into a gap it has created and lending assistance to its own friendly flank units, but the blokes on the end of a line would be mighty cautious about exposing their own back or flanks.
Cheers
Mark
Indeed - and I am talking about what games give - not what is realistic. As was said above there are the limits of toy soldiers stuck on large solid bases, that do limit where they go. But whilst players are cautious about exposing flanks of units, they do so very willing in the perfect information situation they have, when they calculate they are safe to do so.
Games also focus very heavily on the position of units, before and after they have moved, but the actual time spent moving is almost instantaneous - which again gives a very odd perspective on the troops. Computer games like Total War give a much better idea of the time spent by troops moving, rather than jumping from A to B, then standing in B whilst all the other troops move.
But somehow we accept all these compromises as they are what make a game actually playable and fun.
QuoteMost sets of rules also handle exhaustion and attrition very poorly as it adds an extra layer of bookkeeping to an already overloaded gamers mind.
Armati handled both the issue of making breakthrough flanking movements and combat fatigue very well - but it produced a game, that whilst realistic was not popular.
Agree too, particularly on the exhaustion side.
One game that handles attrition very elegantly is Rommel by Sam Mustafa where as combat quality degrades the ability to be effective against enemies drops as well as the unit becoming closer to breaking. And fresh units are super effective when deployed against these.
I'm not familiar with Armati - but realistic and popular rarely go together!
Just to be clear, by FoG I mean Fields of Glory computer game.
If what Mustapha has done in Rommel is similar to Blucher, I fully understand, it isn't casualties, it's fighting effectiveness.
QuoteDesperate measures lads - pass the salt.
;D ;D ;D ;D
Surely garlic mayo with snail?
QuoteMost sets of rules also handle exhaustion and attrition very poorly as it adds an extra layer of bookkeeping to an already overloaded gamers mind.
Armati handled both the issue of making breakthrough flanking movements and combat fatigue very well - but it produced a game, that whilst realistic was not popular.
I can quote some examples and trends regarding exhaustion, attrition and flanking.
WRG 7th introduced exhaustion.
I wasn't part of the "community" at the time, but I understand it was an unpopular idea.
Maybe due to poor implementation rather than being a failed idea.
Impetus provided the "impetus bonus" for fresh units, while worn units don't get the bonus.
To the Strongest tracks missiles, but combat attrition is one (disorder) then done.
Unless you're deep, deep deep, deep deep deep - etc ad infinitium.
The currently fashionable member of the alphabet soup consortium (the one with the coloured cards) does element removal.
Your elements are one and done, but this exhausts the group.
Exhaustion is a bit like D&D hitpoints, we accept that combat is tiring.
A credible presentation requires balance between:
* Few combatants should be immune to melee damage (which takes me back to some truly disappointing ancients games)
* Sufficient damage steps which reduce unit efficiency.
A welcome development is the concept of melee support.
Units get some extras from friends in close proximity.
To me (and this is highly subjective) support feels a lot more credible than forcing a unit to wheel and "shut the door" on a flank.
I like the system Blucher has of Elan. A unit normally starts with 6 Elan (Veterans/Elite more, raw less)
As you get shot at you may lose Elan.
In close combat you lose 1 Elan if you win. Losers can lose more, depending on winning margin.
The number of firing or combat dice you throw is equal to current Elan.
It's not about the numbers - how does the unit feel? It wraps firepower up with morale
WRG 7th was 'unpopular' because Phil had had an epiphany and changed the basis of the game. It wasn't really WRG Ancients 7th Edition it was a different game entirely and after investing in 1 thru 6 most Ancients players hated it.
Think I've worked out where I'm going wrong with FoG II.
Archers (as opposed to Light Archers) are shown as being armed with Bow (obviously) short sword and shield (I assume buckler).
I've been charging armoured cavalry into them and not winning - indeed being held, or even retiring after melee.
I think I've not realised what a negative 'Rough' terrain is on the horse, and not checking that's where they have positioned themselves.
I set up a 'user defined' game - just a row of 9 archer units v 9 Horse. 3 archers are in'Rough', 3 in Fields (open) and 3 in Open.
'Knights and Sergeants' in the open were deadly, but in the rough really struggled. I'm going to read the manual a bit deeper, to see if I can find what 'Rough' is.
Gemini AI thinks this
In Field of Glory II (FOG2), terrain is a decisive factor, and for cavalry, Rough Terrain (such as scrub, rocky ground, or brush) is often a death trap. Unlike infantry, which may only be slightly hindered, cavalry units suffer severe mechanical penalties that strip away their primary advantages.
Here is a breakdown of the specific effects of Rough Terrain on cavalry in melee:
1. The "Disorder" Mechanic
Rough terrain causes cavalry to become Disordered. In FOG2, disorder is one of the most punishing states a unit can have:- Combat Strength Penalty: A disordered unit fights with reduced effective numbers (roughly a 25% penalty to combat power).
- Cohesion Test Penalty: If a disordered unit has to take a Cohesion Test (morale check), it suffers a -1 penalty to the die roll, making it much more likely to drop to "Disrupted," "Fragmented," or "Broken."
2. Loss of "Open Terrain" POAs
Many cavalry units (especially shock cavalry like Lancers, Knights, and Cataphracts) rely on huge Points of Advantage (POA) that are conditional on being in "Open Terrain."- The Rule: If either the attacker or the defender is in non-open terrain (like Rough), the combat is not considered to be in open terrain.
- The Result: Heavy cavalry often gets +100 POA for their lances on the impact phase. In Rough terrain, this bonus is completely lost. This turns a terrifying charge into a weak stumble.
3. Specific Capability Penalties- Mounted Swordsmen: Cavalry units often have "Swordsmen" capabilities for the ongoing melee phase. While swordsmen usually get bonuses against infantry, being Disordered in rough terrain significantly offsets this.
- Medium vs. Heavy Foot: In the open, cavalry can often bully Medium Foot. However, Medium Foot (like Auxilia or Thracians) are not disordered by Rough terrain. This means the infantry fights at 100% efficiency while your cavalry is at ~75%, effectively flipping the odds in favor of the cheaper infantry.
4. Movement and Maneuver
While not strictly "melee combat," these factors dictate how the melee starts:- Higher Movement Cost: It costs more Action Points (AP) for cavalry to move through or turn in Rough terrain. You are much more likely to be caught in a bad position or flanked because you cannot maneuver away.
- No Evasion Bonus: If your light cavalry is caught in rough terrain, their ability to evade an enemy charge is often compromised or slowed, making them easier to pin down and destroy.
Summary Table: Cavalry in Rough Terrain
| Feature | In Open Terrain | In Rough Terrain |
| Status | Steady | Disordered |
| Combat Power | 100% | ~75% |
| Lancer/Impact Bonus | +100 POA (usually) | 0 POA |
| Morale (Cohesion) | Normal | -1 to all tests |
| vs. Medium Foot | Favorable | Highly Unfavorable |
Tactical Tip
If you are playing a cavalry-heavy army (like the Parthians or Mongols), avoid Rough terrain at all costs. If an enemy infantry unit is sitting in a patch of rough ground, do not charge them. Instead, use your horse archers to pepper them with arrows until they are forced to move out or their cohesion breaks.
Yep, that would be it!
The texture for "rough" doesn't really show how rough it is. I wondered what was happening. I noticed in tonight's game, when my knights were absolutely trouncing the computer's units, that made me wonder.
Also explains why its knights wouldn't charge my mounted crossbows, I bet they kept ending up in rough, so it refused to charge; It just stood there while I peppered the unit with 2 of mine.
The game tends to set up most of the horse, especially the heavies, at the back. I redeploy them forward on the flanks.
Tonight it got too caught up with trying to counter these flank attacks,so the foot that did reach my line were easier to overwhelm. I didn't really need to do much with the flanks, I realised it was busy trying to counter that only about half of it's foot reached my line.