Pendraken Miniatures Forum

Wider Wargaming => Batreps => Topic started by: pierre the shy on 13 November 2022, 11:14:36 AM

Title: Battle of Justice Mills 13th Spetember 1644 refought
Post by: pierre the shy on 13 November 2022, 11:14:36 AM
It's very late here and I'm sure Mrs Shy will bend my ear for staying up past my bed time but I did finish a write up of the test game we played on Saturday of Justice Mills, another of Montrose's battles from his very sucessful 1644/45 campaign in Scotland. For a change I have tried to write it in vaguely C17th speak, with comments on the actual game in italics below the pictures. Here is a link to the blog:

https://betweenthelines10mm.blogspot.com/2022/11/battle-of-justice-mills-september-13.html (https://betweenthelines10mm.blogspot.com/2022/11/battle-of-justice-mills-september-13.html)

Any comments/criticisms/compliments gladly accepted. I hope you find the C17th speak comprehensible! ;)   
Title: Re: Battle of Justice Mills 13th Spetember 1644 refought
Post by: Lord Kermit of Birkenhead on 13 November 2022, 11:31:23 AM
Nice report there.
Title: Re: Battle of Justice Mills 13th Spetember 1644 refought
Post by: Duke Speedy of Leighton on 13 November 2022, 02:01:39 PM
Cracking report
Title: Re: Battle of Justice Mills 13th Spetember 1644 refought
Post by: Steve J on 13 November 2022, 03:22:02 PM
Fine report there Pierre 8) .
Title: Re: Battle of Justice Mills 13th Spetember 1644 refought
Post by: paulr on 14 November 2022, 05:13:49 AM
QuoteDespite a fearful charge by Lord Fraiser's pistol armed troop of horse which did much execution amongst the Irishes lead by one Colonel MacDonnell and would have seen them off (3 hits!!)

That was definitely an Oh Feck moment for the Irish, saving all three hits was a 'godsend'  #:-S

An interesting and challenging game. If the Covenanters had got more infantry across to their left it could have all gone pear shaped for the Irish who were starting to run low on ammunition :-SS
Title: Re: Battle of Justice Mills 13th Spetember 1644 refought
Post by: mmcv on 14 November 2022, 08:55:32 AM
Good game.

Apologies if this has been covered elsewhere, but what are you house ruling to give it the more celtic fringe feel?
Title: Re: Battle of Justice Mills 13th Spetember 1644 refought
Post by: pierre the shy on 14 November 2022, 05:38:39 PM
QuoteGood game.

Apologies if this has been covered elsewhere, but what are you house ruling to give it the more celtic fringe feel?

Morning mmcv

Have a look at DGuy's blog:https://in-red-coat-rags-attired.com/for-king-parliament-local-rules/ (https://in-red-coat-rags-attired.com/for-king-parliament-local-rules/)

We are currently working on a few things that will hopefully see the light of day early next year to make  the Celtic fringe more accessable  :-w  :!! 
Title: Re: Battle of Justice Mills 13th Spetember 1644 refought
Post by: mmcv on 14 November 2022, 07:39:14 PM

QuoteMorning mmcv

Have a look at DGuy's blog:https://in-red-coat-rags-attired.com/for-king-parliament-local-rules/ (https://in-red-coat-rags-attired.com/for-king-parliament-local-rules/)

We are currently working on a few things that will hopefully see the light of day early next year to make  the Celtic fringe more accessable  :-w  :!! 
Thanks. I knew dguy had done a lot around those conflicts, but hadn't seen that post on the rules. 


When I finally get my current batch of ECW done I'll probably move things northwards. Slow going as mostly all I have left are horse units, which I can only stomach painting a couple of at a go!
Title: Re: Battle of Justice Mills 13th Spetember 1644 refought
Post by: pierre the shy on 14 November 2022, 11:28:55 PM
We're hoping to get all Montroses stuff sorted out by the end of the year and then move on to various Irish battles up to 1649.
Title: Re: Battle of Justice Mills 13th Spetember 1644 refought
Post by: d_Guy on 15 November 2022, 12:22:20 AM
I liked the report Peter. You and I both seem to draw the worst chits at the worst time! In my play throughs Montrose lost once (catastrophically) and barely won once until he got a result similar to yours!

mmcv: the present download is still basically the original Celtic Fringe extension for FK&P although we are on the 6th revision at the moment. As Pierre said we hope to wrap Montrose (1644/45) in a couple months and then move on to Ireland. We have had to do more tweaks to deal with the 1641 insurgency and the early day of the Confederation.

I visit your blog occasionally. You have a large number irons in the fire!
Title: Re: Battle of Justice Mills 13th Spetember 1644 refought
Post by: mmcv on 15 November 2022, 01:20:24 PM

QuoteI liked the report Peter. You and I both seem to draw the worst chits at the worst time! In my play throughs Montrose lost once (catastrophically) and barely won once until he got a result similar to yours!

mmcv: the present download is still basically the original Celtic Fringe extension for FK&P although we are on the 6th revision at the moment. As Pierre said we hope to wrap Montrose (1644/45) in a couple months and then move on to Ireland. We have had to do more tweaks to deal with the 1641 insurgency and the early day of the Confederation.

I visit your blog occasionally. You have a large number irons in the fire!
I do, I am at times envious of the singular focus you all seem to have on particular projects. I tend to get very focused on a project for a while then once I've a good core of it done I look for a little variety and jump between other projects. I'm trying to be a little more controlled by having one project on the go for a particular era, but what constitutes an "era" can be suitably fuzzy...


I have determined I'm not starting any new ones until I get at least one or two "finished" to a reasonable degree. Very little time for painting at the moment though, so more time for thinking about projects... :-X
Title: Re: Battle of Justice Mills 13th Spetember 1644 refought
Post by: d_Guy on 15 November 2022, 04:38:02 PM
I've been working on this for five years which bespeaks a singular lack of focus  :D Peter actually completed other projects in the same time!

PaulR, among other things, is now editing which has brought much needed discipline!

Yes, thinking about other projects brings those "Look, Squirrel!" moments.
Title: Re: Battle of Justice Mills 13th Spetember 1644 refought
Post by: mmcv on 15 November 2022, 05:19:55 PM
Haha, yeah flitting between projects does take longer, but is more relaxing than just working on one thing, for me anyway. Though I find I usually get a bit of a burst when the end of an army or project is in sight as get a buzz from finishing them. I found I enjoyed painting more when I switched from trying to batch paint 100+ figures in one go to just focusing on painting up a unit (or couple of small units) at a time. Was much more satisfying having something finished after a couple of sittings rather than chipping away for weeks then finishing all at once. Much more motivating. That's partly why I jump projects a well, avoids the temptation to start taking on more and more similar units in one go.
Title: Re: Battle of Justice Mills 13th Spetember 1644 refought
Post by: paulr on 15 November 2022, 06:08:34 PM
Quote... I found I enjoyed painting more when I switched from trying to batch paint 100+ figures in one go to just focusing on painting up a unit (or couple of small units) at a time. Was much more satisfying having something finished after a couple of sittings rather than chipping away for weeks then finishing all at once. Much more motivating...

Absolutely, I recently did a large batch of cavalry then moved back to doing smaller batches of foot. The quicker progress on the smaller batches was much more motivating
Title: Re: Battle of Justice Mills 13th Spetember 1644 refought
Post by: mmcv on 15 November 2022, 06:10:34 PM

QuoteAbsolutely, I recently did a large batch of cavalry then moved back to doing smaller batches of foot. The quicker progress on the smaller batches was much more motivating
Cavalry is the mind killer.
Title: Re: Battle of Justice Mills 13th Spetember 1644 refought
Post by: paulr on 15 November 2022, 06:14:02 PM
I thought it was Fear ;)

I don't mind cavalry, but need to remember to do them in small batches
Title: Re: Battle of Justice Mills 13th Spetember 1644 refought
Post by: pierre the shy on 16 November 2022, 05:59:17 AM
Guess I'm lucky as I'm pretty crap at figure painting to have the services of Paul R who is an really good painter. He has very generously slotted in various batches of 10mm WW 1 and W3K figures of mine into his painting queue over the last few years in return for assistance towards his next project.

I have painted a few 10mm wagon and draft horses myself and found that yes you have to apply yourself to get even small batches of them completed, but I can paint and base 20 odd bases of sheep and cattle in a few days without apparent effort.

I admit to being prone to "Look shiny stuff" moments, though I have been concentating on our W3K stuff lately, I have a few editorial deadlines to meet by the end of the year.... ;) 
Title: Re: Battle of Justice Mills 13th Spetember 1644 refought
Post by: paulr on 16 November 2022, 07:02:38 AM
:!!  :!!  :!!
Title: Re: Battle of Justice Mills 13th Spetember 1644 refought
Post by: mmcv on 16 November 2022, 07:22:06 AM
Yes, I  admire Paul's continued devotion to detail. Manys a project I've started painting socks and belt buckles and doing washes and highlights, but by a few bases in I'm usually just blocking in the major colours and figuring it looks grand from a distance.  ;D
Title: Re: Battle of Justice Mills 13th Spetember 1644 refought
Post by: paulr on 16 November 2022, 07:41:51 AM
I don't always do belt buckles in 10mm and only do obvious socks ;)

I did paint the edges of the pages of the book carried by a couple of British civilians this morning :-B
Title: Re: Battle of Justice Mills 13th Spetember 1644 refought
Post by: mmcv on 16 November 2022, 08:06:48 AM
Devotion!
Title: Re: Battle of Justice Mills 13th Spetember 1644 refought
Post by: Lord Kermit of Birkenhead on 16 November 2022, 11:07:05 AM
How do you know it was a prayer book ?  :d
Title: Re: Battle of Justice Mills 13th Spetember 1644 refought
Post by: d_Guy on 16 November 2022, 05:14:43 PM
QuoteHow do you know it was a prayer book ?  :d

He didn't actually say prayer book but the cover did read "Book of Common Prayer"  ;)